{ "updated": "2026-10-18", "method": "docs/methodology/ranking.md", "board": [ { "rank": 1, "model": "Basilisk", "variant": "Saint-Venant", "key": "basilisk", "organisation": "Basilisk (S. Popinet, CNRS)", "licence": "Open (GPL-3.0)", "rating": 1290.2, "ci95_low": 1190.3, "ci95_high": 1514.8, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 11, "median_percent_difference": 0.021181195548521606, "median_percent_difference_1d": 0.030195857110113144, "median_percent_difference_2d": 0.021181195548521606, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 0.959 }, { "rank": 1, "model": "ANUGA", "variant": "4.0.1", "key": "anuga", "organisation": "Geoscience Australia and ANU", "licence": "Open (Apache-2.0)", "rating": 1218.6, "ci95_low": 1046.7, "ci95_high": 1402.1, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 15, "median_percent_difference": 0.10697696697705705, "median_percent_difference_1d": 0.1091627770202718, "median_percent_difference_2d": 0.019924755218885575, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 27.641 }, { "rank": 1, "model": "LISFLOOD-FP", "variant": "8.3 \u00b7 DG2", "key": "lisflood-dg2", "organisation": "University of Bristol", "licence": "Open (GPL-3.0)", "rating": 1139.5, "ci95_low": 1066.0, "ci95_high": 1215.0, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 13, "median_percent_difference": 0.029652654393926108, "median_percent_difference_1d": 0.17008079040485607, "median_percent_difference_2d": 0.010496293070649606, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 4.395 }, { "rank": 1, "model": "LISFLOOD-FP", "variant": "8.3 \u00b7 FV1", "key": "lisflood-fv1", "organisation": "University of Bristol", "licence": "Open (GPL-3.0)", "rating": 1139.0, "ci95_low": 1031.6, "ci95_high": 1264.2, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 13, "median_percent_difference": 0.03276278976374346, "median_percent_difference_1d": 0.17113087170566887, "median_percent_difference_2d": 0.020402409004678806, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 4.558 }, { "rank": 1, "model": "TELEMAC-2D", "variant": "openTELEMAC 9.1", "key": "telemac", "organisation": "openTELEMAC consortium", "licence": "Open (GPL-3.0)", "rating": 1128.1, "ci95_low": 1035.1, "ci95_high": 1243.6, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 15, "median_percent_difference": 0.0490926097088587, "median_percent_difference_1d": 0.10923667842021578, "median_percent_difference_2d": 0.034217953388692525, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 25.662 }, { "rank": 2, "model": "Hydra", "variant": "urban drainage", "key": "hydra-uds", "organisation": "NEER AI", "licence": "AGPL-3.0 or commercial", "rating": 1015.2, "ci95_low": 888.7, "ci95_high": 1150.2, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 13, "median_percent_difference": 3.840079401033828, "median_percent_difference_1d": 49.180888428246796, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": 5.062006924738682e-05, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 3.913 }, { "rank": 2, "model": "LISFLOOD-FP", "variant": "8.3 \u00b7 ACC", "key": "lisflood-acc", "organisation": "University of Bristol", "licence": "Open (GPL-3.0)", "rating": 986.5, "ci95_low": 842.8, "ci95_high": 1108.4, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 13, "median_percent_difference": 0.4163649008407068, "median_percent_difference_1d": 27.987552230197455, "median_percent_difference_2d": 0.04079320339099402, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 2.315 }, { "rank": 2, "model": "HEC-RAS 7.0", "variant": "1D \u00b7 2D SWE-ELM", "key": "hecras", "organisation": "US Army Corps of Engineers (HEC)", "licence": "Free, closed source", "rating": 960.9, "ci95_low": 732.4, "ci95_high": 1134.5, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 8, "median_percent_difference": 0.4132080259744972, "median_percent_difference_1d": 0.9021814595378937, "median_percent_difference_2d": 0.04104935470509229, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 20.528 }, { "rank": 2, "model": "HEC-RAS 7.0", "variant": "2D \u00b7 SWE-EM", "key": "hecras-em", "organisation": "US Army Corps of Engineers (HEC)", "licence": "Free, closed source", "rating": 951.0, "ci95_low": 713.7, "ci95_high": 1187.5, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 7, "median_percent_difference": 0.7291501455361913, "median_percent_difference_1d": 8.385183321301009, "median_percent_difference_2d": 0.04429398684071564, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 24.63 }, { "rank": 3, "model": "OpenSWMM 6", "variant": "finite volume", "key": "openswmm-fv", "organisation": "HydroCouple", "licence": "Open (MIT)", "rating": 876.3, "ci95_low": 672.4, "ci95_high": 1052.3, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 13, "median_percent_difference": 0.19214376543045394, "median_percent_difference_1d": 0.1566124475665822, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": 0.31177790546385586, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 1.019 }, { "rank": 4, "model": "OpenSWMM 6", "variant": "dynamic wave", "key": "openswmm-dw", "organisation": "HydroCouple", "licence": "Open (MIT)", "rating": 883.8, "ci95_low": 690.8, "ci95_high": 1037.1, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 13, "median_percent_difference": 0.32667575085787115, "median_percent_difference_1d": 54.922353796432134, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": 0.026705904970425465, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 4.103 }, { "rank": 4, "model": "EPA SWMM 5.2.4", "variant": "dynamic wave", "key": "swmm524", "organisation": "US EPA", "licence": "Open (public domain)", "rating": 879.5, "ci95_low": 699.7, "ci95_high": 1039.5, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 13, "median_percent_difference": 0.32667575085787115, "median_percent_difference_1d": 56.381403891067556, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": 0.026705904970425465, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 3.922 }, { "rank": 7, "model": "Landlab", "variant": "OverlandFlow", "key": "landlab", "organisation": "Landlab (CSDMS)", "licence": "Open (MIT)", "rating": 791.6, "ci95_low": 640.0, "ci95_high": 885.3, "not_ranked_because": null, "tests": 9, "median_percent_difference": 13.284373042183518, "median_percent_difference_1d": 28.179984635395105, "median_percent_difference_2d": 0.581592103168635, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 1.33 }, { "rank": null, "model": "GeoClaw", "variant": "Clawpack 5.9", "key": "geoclaw", "organisation": "Clawpack developers", "licence": "Open (BSD-3)", "rating": null, "ci95_low": null, "ci95_high": null, "not_ranked_because": "fewer than 5 tests", "tests": 4, "median_percent_difference": 0.14054650492433424, "median_percent_difference_1d": 0.09195655169379918, "median_percent_difference_2d": 0.1891364581548693, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 2.137 }, { "rank": null, "model": "HEC-RAS 7.0", "variant": "pipe networks \u00b7 1D/2D", "key": "hecras-pipes", "organisation": "US Army Corps of Engineers (HEC)", "licence": "Free, closed source", "rating": null, "ci95_low": null, "ci95_high": null, "not_ranked_because": "no test shared with the rated models", "tests": 3, "median_percent_difference": 7.58174466301065, "median_percent_difference_1d": null, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": 7.58174466301065, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 17.752 }, { "rank": null, "model": "OpenSWMM 6", "variant": "coupled 1D/2D", "key": "openswmm-2d", "organisation": "HydroCouple", "licence": "Open (MIT)", "rating": null, "ci95_low": null, "ci95_high": null, "not_ranked_because": "no test shared with the rated models", "tests": 3, "median_percent_difference": 0.7892006216451004, "median_percent_difference_1d": null, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": 0.7892006216451004, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 3.513 }, { "rank": null, "model": "OpenSWMM 6", "variant": "coupled 1D/2D \u00b7 cross mesh", "key": "openswmm-2d-x", "organisation": "HydroCouple", "licence": "Open (MIT)", "rating": null, "ci95_low": null, "ci95_high": null, "not_ranked_because": "no test shared with the rated models", "tests": 3, "median_percent_difference": 10.317408019453575, "median_percent_difference_1d": null, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": 10.317408019453575, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 8.14 }, { "rank": null, "model": "EPANET 2.2", "variant": "US EPA", "key": "epanet22", "organisation": "US EPA", "licence": "Open (public domain)", "rating": null, "ci95_low": null, "ci95_high": null, "not_ranked_because": "no test shared with the rated models", "tests": 2, "median_percent_difference": 0.6036766113524854, "median_percent_difference_1d": null, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": 0.6036766113524854, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 0.564 }, { "rank": null, "model": "Hydra", "variant": "water distribution", "key": "hydra-wds", "organisation": "NEER AI", "licence": "AGPL-3.0 or commercial", "rating": null, "ci95_low": null, "ci95_high": null, "not_ranked_because": "no test shared with the rated models", "tests": 2, "median_percent_difference": 0.34028281453443887, "median_percent_difference_1d": null, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": 0.34028281453443887, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 0.5285 }, { "rank": null, "model": "HydroNet", "variant": "finite volume", "key": "hydronet-fvm", "organisation": "Penn State", "licence": "Open (MIT)", "rating": null, "ci95_low": null, "ci95_high": null, "not_ranked_because": "fewer than 5 tests", "tests": 2, "median_percent_difference": 31.69748541468772, "median_percent_difference_1d": 31.69748541468772, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 1.8565 }, { "rank": null, "model": "HydroNet", "variant": "FVM-PINN", "key": "hydronet-pinn", "organisation": "Penn State", "licence": "Open (MIT)", "rating": null, "ci95_low": null, "ci95_high": null, "not_ranked_because": "fewer than 5 tests", "tests": 2, "median_percent_difference": 106.63035211696129, "median_percent_difference_1d": 106.63035211696129, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": null, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": null }, { "rank": null, "model": "WNTR", "variant": "own hydraulic solver", "key": "wntr", "organisation": "US EPA and Sandia", "licence": "Open (BSD-3)", "rating": null, "ci95_low": null, "ci95_high": null, "not_ranked_because": "no test shared with the rated models", "tests": 1, "median_percent_difference": 0.0013242846246332473, "median_percent_difference_1d": null, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": 0.0013242846246332473, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": 0.075 }, { "rank": null, "model": "TSNet", "variant": "water hammer \u00b7 MOC", "key": "tsnet", "organisation": "University of Texas at Austin", "licence": "Open (MIT)", "rating": null, "ci95_low": null, "ci95_high": null, "not_ranked_because": "no test shared with the rated models", "tests": 0, "median_percent_difference": 0.131168292060995, "median_percent_difference_1d": null, "median_percent_difference_2d": null, "median_percent_difference_drainage": null, "median_percent_difference_water": 0.131168292060995, "median_percent_difference_coupled": null, "median_percent_difference_field": null, "median_percent_difference_parity": null, "median_run_time_s": null } ] }